Dino Polska Deep Dive
Welcome to the 73rd Pari Passu Newsletter.
In this edition of Pari Passu, we will be conducted a deep dive into one of the exciting grocery companies of today, Dino Polska from Poland. Since the nation's pivotal shift away from communism in 1990, a fresh breed of private enterprises has emerged, navigating through the nascent market dynamics.
Among these, Dino stands out for its strategic acumen and efficiency. Dino adheres to a meticulously crafted playbook, focusing on penetrating small towns. This strategy involves the replication of a consistent store format across its outlets, a move that not only enhances efficiency but also facilitates reinvestment into new locations. This blend of strategic foresight and efficient execution has positioned Dino as a formidable player in the sector, setting the stage for its growth and innovation.
While a deep dive on a European retailer might not appear exciting at first, there are a myriad of investing lessons to be learned, let’s dive in.
But first, a message from a stellar sponsor, Select
Select’s Founder has long been a fan of Pari Passu and we have finally partnered to offer you access to the next-generation black card, concierge, and membership community for only $395/year (typically $495/year) + $200 credit toward your first Select hotel or restaurant booking. If you are a value investor, you will love this offer.
Select members enjoy unpublished rates or VIP status at over 500,000 hotels & resorts and VIP perks and pricing at thousands of premier restaurants, retailers, and experiences.
Take Your Life to the Next Level
Once you’re a SELECT member, it’s hard to imagine life without a dedicated concierge, members-only events, guest list access at the hottest clubs, free drinks at the trendiest restaurants, and private rates at properties across the globe.
Section 1: History
The New Poland
To understand Dino Polska, we need to understand the country where it is based, Poland. The fall of communism in Poland in the 1990s marked a pivotal turning point in the nation's history, catalyzing a dramatic transformation in its business landscape, particularly in the retail and grocery sectors [4].
Prior to this period, Poland's economy was predominantly state-controlled, with private enterprise and market-driven competition nearly nonexistent
The transition to capitalism not only introduced Poland to new economic dynamics but also laid the foundation for an era of unprecedented growth and development
As Poland embraced capitalism, the country underwent rapid economic changes, including significant product innovation and improvements in standards of living that had to be cultivated from the ground up
This period of transformation was characterized by an explosive growth in GDP per capita, which increased tenfold, showcasing one of the fastest growth rates globally during that time.
This economic resurgence was instrumental in shaping the grocery retail landscape we see in Poland today
The 1990s saw the emergence or entry of dominant grocery chains, both local and multinational, marking the beginning of a highly competitive retail sector
Unlike in countries with century-old retail giants, Poland's grocery chains have their roots in this relatively recent shift, making the last two to three decades a critical period for the establishment and expansion of these businesses
The rapid economic advancements, however, have not uniformly translated into wealth across the population [4].
Despite the tenfold increase in GDP per capita, the average standard of living in Poland remains comparatively modest, especially when viewed through the lens of purchasing power parity
This economic indicator, which adjusts for the cost of goods and services and currency differences, reveals that the median income in Poland is about one-fifth of that in the U.S., with the cost of goods and services approximately half
Consequently, the purchasing power of the average Polish consumer is significantly lower, allowing for only about 35% of the expenditure on goods and services compared to the average American
This disparity underscores the inherent price sensitivity among Polish consumers, a trait that profoundly influences consumer behavior, especially in the realm of grocery shopping.
This backdrop of economic evolution and consumer behavior has critically influenced the strategic approaches of grocery retailers in Poland [1].
Chains like Dino Polska have adeptly tailored their operations to meet the specific needs of this market, emphasizing affordability, proximity, and efficiency
The historical context of Poland's transition from communism to capitalism provides a nuanced understanding of the current retail environment, highlighting the adaptability and resilience of businesses in navigating the challenges and opportunities presented by this transformation
A New Store is Born
The history of Dino Polska is intimately tied to its founder, Tomasz Biernacki, a visionary entrepreneur who embarked on his journey in the grocery retail industry at the young age of 26 [6].
Establishing Dino in 1999 in the rural town of Krotoszyn, Poland, with a modest population of around 29,000, Biernacki has been instrumental in steering the company from its nascent stages to its current status as a leading proximity supermarket chain
Under his leadership, Dino has remained true to its roots, with its headquarters still based in Krotoszyn, reflecting a deep connection to its origins and a commitment to serving the communities that form its customer base
In the formative years of Dino, Biernacki's approach was characterized by experimentation with various grocery formats, including franchising and directly owned stores, across both urban and rural settings
Despite Dino's current strategic focus on small-town Poland, some urban stores from this early period remain operational, testament to their enduring profitability and the adaptability of Dino's business model.
Through this phase of exploration and refinement, Biernacki identified and honed Dino's unique market niche: a proximity supermarket tailored to the needs and preferences of small-town residents, offering a full assortment of groceries at competitive prices
A key differentiator for Dino under Biernacki's leadership has been its aggressive pricing strategy
By adopting a policy of matching the prices of its top-selling SKUs to those of the lowest-priced competitors, Dino positioned itself uniquely among proximity supermarkets
This approach not only underscored Dino's commitment to affordability but also enhanced its appeal to cost-conscious consumers, setting it apart in a competitive landscape
Moreover, Biernacki's background in the meat processing industry, owing to his family's pioneering role in this sector, provided Dino with a distinctive edge.
The incorporation of fresh meat counters in Dino stores, offering a variety of meats, including traditional Polish staples like pork and chicken, distinguished Dino from its competitors, many of whom relied on pre-packaged meat products
This strategic decision not only catered to the Polish palate but also allowed Dino to leverage vertical integration with its own meat processing plants, resulting in higher efficiency, lower spoilage rates, and improved gross margins for its fresh meat offerings
These strategic decisions—focusing on competitive pricing, catering to the specific tastes of the Polish market with fresh meat counters, and maintaining a strong commitment to the communities it serves—have been central to Dino's success
Tomasz Biernacki's vision and entrepreneurial acumen have not only shaped Dino's trajectory but have also contributed significantly to its reputation as a retailer that genuinely understands and meets the needs of its customers, embodying a blend of innovation, tradition, and community focus that continues to drive its growth and popularity.
Maintaining a Moat
The year 2010 stands as a watershed moment in Dino Polska's history, marking a strategic pivot that would fundamentally alter the trajectory of its expansion and solidify its position in the Polish retail landscape [1].
At this juncture, with 111 stores in operation, Tomasz Biernacki sought to accelerate Dino's growth through a significant shift in the company's store development strategy
Moving away from the traditional model of renting or leasing retail spaces—a common practice among retailers—Biernacki embraced a bold vision of purchasing real estate plots to construct new stores from the ground up
This transition was not only a departure from conventional retail expansion tactics but also enabled an unprecedented standardization across Dino stores, thanks to Biernacki's foresight in establishing a dedicated construction company for this purpose
To fuel this ambitious expansion plan, Biernacki entered into a partnership with a private equity firm, Enterprise Investors, trading a 49% stake in Dino for approximately $66mm.
This infusion of capital was instrumental in propelling Dino's growth, allowing the company to increase its store count from 111 in 2010 to 628 by the end of 2016
This period of rapid expansion underscored Dino's commitment to a differentiated grocery model, leveraging its own real estate and customized store designs to enhance operational efficiency and customer experience
The partnership with Enterprise Investors reached a pivotal juncture in early 2017 when the firm sought to exit its investment
The decision to pursue an IPO emerged as the most practical solution for facilitating this exit, leading to Dino's debut on the Warsaw Stock Exchange in April 2017
The IPO, priced at 34.5 zloty per share or a $414mm valuation, was a resounding success, significantly rewarding Enterprise Investors and illustrating the substantial value Dino had created for its shareholders [8]
Since the IPO, the remarkable growth trajectory of Dino Polska has continued unabated, with the founder retaining a majority ownership stake and playing an active role in the company's strategic direction alongside a top management team that has been with Dino since 2002
Today, Dino Polska is a colossus in the Polish grocery sector, operating 2400+ stores and generating annual revenues exceeding $5bn, with a market capitalization of $10bn [2].
This impressive scale and financial performance are a testament to the efficacy of Dino's expansion strategy and its unwavering focus on organic growth.
Since 2010, Dino has achieved a CAGR of ~30% in store count, paralleled by similar growth in sales and an even more remarkable EPS growth rate of over 40%.
Moreover, Dino has consistently delivered returns on capital and equity exceeding 20% and 30%, respectively, showcasing not only the company's robust financial health but also its enduring commitment to creating shareholder value
This trajectory from a strategic pivot in 2010 to the retail powerhouse Dino is today encapsulates a journey of visionary leadership, strategic innovation, and unwavering commitment to growth and operational excellence
Section 2: Overview
Poland and the Grocery Model
Poland's grocery industry presents a multifaceted landscape, deeply influenced by the dichotomy between urban and rural settings. This divergence manifests notably in consumer behavior, pricing strategies, and the types of grocery outlets that flourish in each environment [2].
Urban areas, characterized by their denser populations and higher living costs, host grocery stores that diverge significantly in layout, embrace higher product prices due to elevated rent and wage expenses, and cater to a clientele with a penchant for premium, non-staple food items
This urban consumer base displays lesser price sensitivity, opting for luxury goods ranging from hot, ready-made meals to organic products
Conversely, rural communities, marked by their heightened price sensitivity, exhibit a preference for a consistent array of staple groceries, underscoring the stark contrast in grocery consumption patterns across Poland
The grocery sector is segmented into several categories, including hypermarkets, large supermarkets, proximity supermarkets like Dino, discounters, convenience stores, soft franchises, and traditional mom and pop shops [6].
These categories differentiate themselves through various dimensions such as store size, product range, pricing, proximity to customers, and franchising decisions
A notable trend over the past decade has been the significant market share shift towards small format chains, which have been encroaching on the territories traditionally dominated by mom and pop stores and larger grocery formats
This shift is illustrated by the stark reduction in the total number of grocery stores from nearly 170,000 in 2010 to around 100,000 twelve years later, largely at the expense of mom and pop establishments
These traditional stores have struggled to compete with modern chains that offer more attractive store environments, lower prices, and superior product assortments
In response to changing consumer preferences, which increasingly favor convenience over the extensive selection offered by large supermarkets, major grocery chains like Tesco and Carrefour have been adapting by closing down larger outlets, exiting the market, or pivoting towards smaller, more conveniently located store concepts [2].
This consumer-driven shift towards convenience has been a boon for small format stores such as Dino, positioning them favorably within the evolving grocery landscape
As Poland's grocery industry continues to transform, these dynamics underscore the importance of adaptability and strategic alignment with consumer preferences, heralding a new era of retail that prioritizes efficiency, accessibility, and tailored shopping experiences
Dino carves out a distinct niche within Poland's grocery sector through a combination of strategic location choices, store format, and product offerings [1].
Dino distinguishes itself as a proximity supermarket chain
This category is characterized by its comprehensive grocery selection yet compact store size, enabling locations to be more accessible to consumers, especially when compared to larger supermarket formats
Dino's strategic focus is on catering to small town Poland, regions that encompass 80% of the country's population—a demographic that has remained remarkably stable since the 1980s
This focus aligns perfectly with Dino's store offerings, which comprise approximately ~5,000 SKUs, predominantly grocery products, alongside a smaller selection of non-food items (for reference, Costco warehouses keep ~4,000 SKUs, and Walmart store keep ~140,000 SKUs)
The product mix is deliberately curated to meet nearly all of an average consumer's grocery needs, emphasizing grocery staples without delving into luxury or extravagant items
The typical Dino store encompasses about 4,300 square feet, a footprint that from an American perspective, might resemble a considerably larger version of a convenience store, both in terms of depth and product range. For reference, Costco warehouses take up 150,000 square feet, and Walmart 200,000.
The store layout is pragmatic and straightforward, featuring a front area with cash registers and non-food items, leading to four or five grocery aisles, and culminating at the back with sections dedicated to fruits and vegetables, frozen foods, and a fresh meat counter
What sets Dino apart in the competitive grocery landscape is its unique ability to offer a full assortment of groceries at low prices, within small format stores strategically positioned in small towns across Poland.
This model not only provides convenience by situating stores minutes away from consumers' homes but also ensures the availability of competitive pricing
Dino's success formula hinges on its capability to serve areas with low population densities, a feat unmatched by larger format competitors, thereby cementing its role as a critical grocery provider to its targeted demographic
Dino Polska’s Uniqueness & Performance
Dino Polska's approach to pricing and margins sets it apart in the fiercely competitive grocery industry, an arena traditionally marked by slim profit margins [6].
The core strategies for managing a low-price business typically hinge on balancing lower prices with higher volumes or leveraging scale to reduce input costs, thereby maintaining competitive margins
Dino operates with a nuanced mastery of these tactics, demonstrating an adeptness not only in volume management but also in securing advantageous terms with suppliers, thus enhancing their bargaining power as they expand
This strategy has facilitated a gross margin of 25%, on par with notable global counterparts (for instance, Dollar Tree and General hover around 30%), yet Dino distinguishes itself with a pretax margin of 7.5%, outpacing the industry average
This remarkable margin performance can be attributed to several key operational efficiencies.
Dino's practice of purchasing land and constructing their own stores introduces higher initial costs but yields long-term savings by eliminating rental expenses, which traditionally siphon off approximately 3% of revenue.
This investment in real estate, coupled with the strategic vertical integration with their own meat processing facilities and minimal advertising expenditures, further amplifies their margin efficiency.
Unlike many competitors who rely heavily on marketing to draw in customers, Dino leverages its proximity and competitive pricing as its primary attractors, underscoring a value proposition that resonates deeply with its target demographic.
The symbiotic relationship between Dino and its construction arm, Krot-Invest, owned entirely by Dino's chairman, represents a strategic advantage unique within the industry. However, the close ties between Dino and Krot-Invest prompt scrutiny regarding potential conflicts of interest, given the shared ownership by Dino's chairman [2].
This arrangement facilitates the rapid and standardized construction of Dino stores, ensuring a consistent store layout and experience across locations
With over 1,000 stores constructed to date, this partnership underscores a level of operational predictability and efficiency unmatched by competitors
Each Dino store, standardized at approximately 4,300 square feet and offering a consistent range of SKUs, exemplifies the company's commitment to replicability and efficiency
Despite these concerns, rigorous audits and financial disclosures have consistently demonstrated transparency and fairness in dealings between Dino and Krot-Invest
The disclosed costs of construction align with industry standards, mitigating fears of undue enrichment at the company's expense
Furthermore, the strategic and financial logic for the chairman to maintain this integrity is compelling; any short-term gains from inflated construction costs are vastly outweighed by the long-term value of Dino's market position and the chairman's substantial equity stake
This careful balance of efficiency, transparency, and strategic growth underpins Dino Polska's distinguished position in the Polish grocery market, positioning it for sustained success
The economics of opening a new Dino store reveal a compelling narrative of strategic investment and operational efficiency, anchored by the company's philosophy of owning the real estate on which its stores are built [2].
The initial investment required to open a Dino store is approximately $650,000, encompassing both the construction costs and the expenses associated with stocking the store's initial inventory
The process from obtaining permits to completing construction spans roughly 23 to 24 months, with an additional periodic investment of around $36,000 every six years for store maintenance, averaging to a modest $6,000 annually
Dino's inventory turnover rate of ~10 times annually (which compared to ~12 for Costco and ~9 for Walmart), combined with an average cost of goods sold of about $1.2mm, necessitates a working capital of approximately $130,000 for inventory.
Operational costs are streamlined, primarily consisting of salaries for a few cashiers and a store manager, alongside essential utilities
This lean operational model enables a Dino store to reach maturity within three years, at which point it generates annual revenues of around $1.8mm
Mature stores not only achieve, but often exceed, the pace of food inflation, underscoring the brand's robust growth and market acceptance
The financial metrics further underscore Dino's operational prowess, with a gross margin of 25% and an operating margin conservatively estimated at 8% after accounting for centralized overheads [2].
The ROIC for a Dino store oscillates between 20% and 30%, showcasing exceptional efficiency and profitability
Notably, Dino's operational excellence is reflected in its track record of never having to close an owned store since 2007, a testament to the brand's sustainability and strategic site selection
Financing this growth trajectory has been meticulously managed, with Dino leveraging its operations to fund expansion [6].
Since taking equity in 2010 from a private equity partner, Dino has eschewed further equity issuance and dividends, choosing instead to reinvest an average of 96% of its cash from operations back into the business
This reinvestment strategy is supplemented by a prudent use of debt, current leverage sits at 1.1x
This approach underscores management's long-term vision and commitment to growth, prioritizing expansion over immediate shareholder returns
This strategic financial management has positioned Dino for sustained expansion, with the only foreseeable challenge being the efficient allocation of its robust operating cash flows as the pace of new store openings reaches its optimal limit
Now here for Dino’s financial performance for the twelve months ending September 29, 2023, with a current market cap of $10bn [3]:
Revenue: Dino recorded revenue of $5.7bn, a 37% increase year-over-year
Gross Profit: Dino recorded gross profit of $1.3bn, a 30% increase YoY
EBITDA: Dino recorded EBITDA of $511mm (~10% margin), a 32% increase YoY
Net Income: Dino recorded net income of $322mm (~6% margin), a 34% increase YoY
CapEx: Dino recorded capital expenditures of $267mm (~5% of revenues)
Section 3: Contemplating the Future
Opportunities
Looking ahead, Dino Polska's growth prospects appear robust, buoyed by a largely untapped market opportunity within Poland's grocery sector [2].
The TAM for groceries in Poland is estimated at approximately $60bn, with a significant portion of consumer spending occurring outside the urban centers
Adjusting for the demographic distribution and price differentials between urban and rural areas, it's estimated that about $45bn, or 75% of the consumer grocery spend, is up for grabs in Dino's primary market—outside large cities
This analysis sets the stage for assessing Dino's potential market penetration and growth trajectory
Dino's stronghold in its founding town of Krotoszyn, where it commands an impressive 45% to 46% market share, serves as a benchmark for its mature market potential
Extrapolating from this, Dino could potentially target a nationwide market share translating to about $20bn in sales or 11,500 stores, assuming a similar saturation across Poland
On a more conservative note, drawing parallels with Biedronka, Dino's most formidable competitor with a 25% market share, suggests a more modest TAM for Dino of just over $11bn in sales, or approximately 6,000 stores, representing a substantial expansion from its current footprint
Moreover, the prospect of international expansion looms as a tantalizing avenue for Dino's growth, albeit with caution due to the uncharted nature of such a move [5].
The neighboring countries of the Czech Republic, Slovakia, and Lithuania represent potential markets for Dino, given their demographic and economic similarities to Poland
This opportunity, while speculative, could effectively double Dino's addressable market should the company decide to venture beyond its domestic borders
Despite Dino's impressive growth, significant room remains for further expansion within the Polish grocery market, particularly at the expense of mom-and-pop stores, which constitute a considerable portion of the market.
The structural decline of these traditional retailers, accelerated by the economic fallout from COVID-19 and generational shifts in business ownership, presents a ripe opportunity for Dino to capture additional market share
Furthermore, while formidable players like Biedronka may not cede ground easily, there exists a substantial segment of the market comprised of higher-priced proximity supermarkets and large format stores, both of which are increasingly misaligned with consumer preferences for convenience and value
Dino's strategic positioning, coupled with its operational efficiencies and pricing competitiveness, positions it well to capitalize on these opportunities [6].
The company's potential to grow its store count and market share, both domestically and potentially internationally, underscores a promising outlook
To realize this potential, Dino will need to maintain a growth rate that allows it to steadily close the gap with its competitors, leveraging the ongoing market fragmentation and shifting consumer preferences in its favor
With a current revenue base, capturing an additional 5% to 10% of the market from less competitive formats appears feasible, especially given the structural challenges facing the traditional mom-and-pop segment
This strategic approach, balanced with mindful expansion and market dynamics, heralds a future of sustained growth and increasing market dominance for Dino Polska
Challenges
Looking into the future, the resilience of Dino Polska's revenue streams amidst macroeconomic fluctuations presents a robust picture, largely attributed to its strategic positioning within the grocery sector [7].
Despite the historical economic stability in Poland, recent events such as the conflict in neighboring Ukraine and resultant inflationary pressures have tested the resilience of various businesses
Dino, however, has demonstrated commendable stability in its gross margins, slightly adjusting by about 20 basis points year-over-year in challenging times, showcasing its ability to withstand economic headwinds
Dino's status as the lowest price grocer in small town Poland positions it uniquely as an essential service, particularly in times of economic hardship.
When faced with rising living costs, consumers tend to prioritize essential purchases such as groceries, naturally gravitating towards retailers that offer the most value, like Dino
This dynamic not only helps sustain Dino's existing customer base but potentially expands it as more people seek cost-effective shopping options
Historical data supports this resilience, with Dino's like-for-like sales consistently outpacing food inflation and demonstrating strong growth across various economic conditions
The geopolitical tension arising from the Russia-Ukraine conflict poses a significant concern, with the potential spillover into Poland representing a catastrophic risk.
While the probability of such an event is deemed low, thanks to NATO's united stance and commitments to defend its members, the implications of any escalation would be severe for businesses and the country at large
On the flip side, the influx of Ukrainian refugees into Poland has temporarily boosted the consumer base for retailers like Dino, potentially offsetting some of the negative impacts from the broader geopolitical situation
Inflation and rising energy and food prices remain immediate concerns, though these are viewed as relatively transient in nature [7].
The company's low-price strategy may serve as a hedge in such times, attracting budget-conscious consumers and maintaining sales volumes
Looking further ahead, the challenge of reinvesting Dino's substantial cash flows poses a strategic dilemma
Options such as share buybacks or international expansion could provide avenues for utilizing excess capital efficiently, with the latter offering a path to sustained growth beyond the Polish market
Increased competition and the potential erosion of store economics represent ongoing risks.
Yet, Dino's unique value proposition, coupled with its operational efficiencies, positions it well to continue capturing market share from less competitive players
The rivalry with Biedronka, while notable, is framed more as a shared opportunity to dominate the market by appealing to value-seeking consumers, rather than a direct threat
Lessons Learned
The exploration of Dino Polska's journey from its humble beginnings to becoming a formidable force in the Polish grocery market reveals a wealth of strategic insights and lessons for investors and business leaders.
Central to these lessons is the realization that significant opportunities exist beyond the familiar terrains of domestic markets, often in places less carefully analyzed by the mainstream investment community
Dino's story underscores the potential of international markets to harbor businesses that are not only exceptional in their operational execution but also present unique investment prospects, potentially undervalued or overlooked in comparison to their more visible U.S. counterparts
The essence of Dino Polska's success lies in its deep understanding of its niche—providing accessible, affordable, and convenient grocery options to small-town Poland [6].
This clarity of purpose, coupled with a disciplined approach to growth and capital allocation, has been pivotal
Tomasz Biernacki's strategic vision and long-term financial decisions have propelled Dino to capture and sustain abnormal profits, emphasizing the importance of finding and dominating a niche market
For investors, Dino's trajectory illuminates the significance of recognizing and valuing the unique competitive advantages that companies cultivate, particularly those operating in sectors or regions that may initially appear less attractive.
It also highlights the importance of patience and a long-term perspective when assessing the potential of a business
The ability to identify companies with a clear understanding of their market position, coupled with robust operational strategies and the discipline to reinvest capital judiciously, is crucial
Moreover, Dino's story teaches the criticality of adaptability and resilience in the face of macroeconomic fluctuations and external shocks. The potential for international expansion highlights the importance of not being constrained by existing geographical boundaries.
Its ability to maintain stable margins and grow its customer base, even in challenging times, speaks to the strength of its business model and the essential nature of its offerings
This resilience is a key attribute for businesses aiming to sustain growth and profitability over the long term
While the core business should always be the focus, the readiness to explore growth opportunities in new markets can pave the way for sustained success.
Sources: [1], [2], [3], [4], [5], [6], [7], [8]
How did you like this week’s Pari Passu? Loved | Great | Good | Meh | Bad
In case you missed the latest Pari Passu Newsletters:
Interested in our updated reading / wellness list? Check it out here.
Got Feedback? Just hit Reply. Seriously, I would love to get your thoughts.
Interested in our IB / PE / Finance course recommendation? Check it out here.
Looking to reach 7,000+ investors, bankers, lawyers?
Looking for more Pari Passu Content? Check out Instagram | Twitter | Linkedln